One of my old friends puts it like this: “What you’re supposed to acquire during your four years in college is a built-in Bull Shit Detector—every time you’re exposed to bull shit the detector sounds a warning signal inside your head.”
Imagine trying to convert an English-speaking Humanoid Space Alien with a built-in BS Detector to the Christian religion. The conversation might go something like this:
YOU: Hey pal, have I got a great religion for you.
HSA: Tell me about it.
YOU: Well it all begins here on Earth a little over two-thousand years ago.
HSA: What happened?
YOU: God came to life in the form of a human being.
HSA: How do you know?
YOU: Well, it’s in the Bible for one thing.
HSA: What’s the Bible?
YOU: It’s a very old book where all of this is written down.
HSA: Who wrote it down?
YOU: Lots of different people; but the ones we’re interested in are four guys named Mark, Matthew, Luke and John—plus St. Paul.
HSA: Did they write about things they saw and heard or did they write about things that were reported to them?
YOU: Some say they wrote about things they actually saw and heard but most scholars say they wrote about things that were reported to them.
HSA: I see. How long after these things happened did they do their writing?
YOU: Some scholars say a few years later, others say decades.
HSA: So you’re telling me I should believe things written years after they supposedly happened by people who weren’t around at the time—second-hand stuff, hearsay.
YOU: Well, millions of humans have believed in it for thousands of years.
HSA: I have no doubt about that. But why should I believe it?
YOU: Because if you do you’ll be saved.
HSA: Saved from what?
YOU: Saved from having your soul end up in hell for eternity for one thing.
HSA: What’s a soul?
YOU: It’s a part of you that’s immaterial but it lasts for eternity.
HSA: It’s in me, it’s a part of me, but there’s no way of detecting it?
YOU: That’s right. And when you die it goes on living.
HSA: How does it live without me to keep it alive?
YOU: It’s existence does not depend on you.
HSA: You mean it existed before I was born?
YOU: No. It came into existence the moment you were conceived.
HSA: So, if I’m following what you’re saying, it wasn’t in the egg and it wasn’t in the sperm but it came into existence when they merged to make me.
YOU: That’s exactly right.
HSA: How can it “come into existence” if it has no dimensions.
YOU: It has a spiritual existence. It is not a physical thing.
HSA: But its existence begins with a physical event—a sperm meeting up with an egg.
YOU: Yes, that’s so. But it has no prior existence.
HSA: How does it get implanted in the fertilized egg? It must be “within it” somehow.
YOU: God creates it and implants it at the instant of conception.
HSA: So God waits patiently while millions of sperms swim around an egg. The instant one of them penetrates it he inserts a soul in the fertilized egg. All of this is invisible and leaves no traces—no DNA, no nothing.
YOU: You’ve got it.
HSA: And the fertilized eggs that don’t make it as living babies—what happens to their souls?
YOU: They are also immortal and eternal.
HSA: And where do they end up?
YOU: It’s another place—an immaterial place—known as limbo.
HSA: What’s it like?
YOU: Not much is known about it, but it’s a place of no pain and no suffering. The souls in limbo are denied the Presence of God.
HSA: Why not? Did they do something bad? Suppose they were part of a miscarriage or in an aborted fetus—it’s not their fault they were miscarried or aborted or whatever.
YOU: Yes, but they can’t be allowed to go to Heaven with the Good Souls and they can’t be sent to Hell with the bad ones.
HSA: Why can’t they go to heaven? They’re immaterial—they won’t use up any space.
YOU: It’s not a question of space, it’s a question of deserving.
HSA: For a soul to get into Heaven it must deserve to get there.
YOU: That’s right.
HSA: And God decides which ones make it and which ones don’t.
YOU: Yes, you’re catching on.
HSA: What about the ones that don’t make it—what happens to them.
YOU: They go to Hell where they spend eternity being tortured.
HSA: Wow. They must be really, really bad to deserve that. Does anyone go to Hell?
YOU: I’m sure the soul of Adolph Hitler and lots of other top Nazis are there.
HSA: And they are there for eternity?
HSA: Isn’t that taking things too far. Even if Hitler or Himmler, or any of the others, had to serve a century in hell for each and every Holocaust victim that would be around 600,000,000 years—far less than eternity.
YOU: These things aren’t intended to be taken literally?
HSA: Not taken literally? Then how are they to be taken? With a grain of salt.
YOU: God’s punishments and His rewards are just. That’s what matters. Good people are rewarded and bad people are punished.
HSA: Is there any evidence of any sort that supports any of this?
YOU: I suppose it all depends on what you call evidence.
HSA: I was afraid of that. Well it’s been an interesting chat. And now I must be off.
YOU: Your soul could end up in Hell!
HSA: If your God is just, it won’t. Think about it.